# My Child Is a Perfectionist: Helping Them Try, Write and Make Mistakes

> Perfectionist child? The signs, how it differs from high standards, and how to help them start, write a messy first draft, read aloud and make mistakes calmly.

The text of https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/my-child-is-a-perfectionist, as markdown.

Signs of perfectionism in children, how it differs from high standards, and practical ways to help them start, write a messy first draft, read aloud without fear and make mistakes in front of you.

By Bookstaken 19 November 2026 7 min read

The story was nearly finished. Then one letter came out wrong.

Your daughter rubs it out. Then the word. Then the whole line, until there's a hole in the paper and tears on the table.

Perfectionist children aren't trying to be difficult. They care so much about getting it right that starting, or finishing, feels risky. Here's how to spot it, and how to help them try, write and make mistakes.

In this article

- In short
- Signs your child may be a perfectionist
- High standards, or perfectionism?
- What helps
- Writing: the messy first draft
- Reading aloud without fear
- Books where characters get it wrong
- By age
- When to get more help
- A story, chapter by chapter
- Questions parents ask
- Sources

## In short

- **Perfectionism often looks like avoidance:** not starting, not finishing, not trying anything new.
- **Praise the effort and the process,** not the result or being clever (Mueller and Dweck, 1998).
- **Make mistakes normal:** share your own, out loud, and show what you do next.
- **Separate writing from fixing:** a messy first draft first, corrections later.
- **For reading aloud,** let them practise in private first.

[Find 7 books picked for your child Free · quick questions Start the book hunt](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations) [A free 1:1 reading session No payment details needed Book their free session](https://bookstaken.com/freeTrial)

## Signs your child may be a perfectionist

- They rub out again and again, or tear up the page and start over.
- They won't start until they're sure they'll get it right.
- Small mistakes bring tears or anger.
- They avoid reading aloud or answering in class.
- They only do things they're already good at.
- Homework takes far longer than it should, because nothing is ever quite finished.
- They brush off praise: "It's not good enough."

These are common signs, not a diagnosis. Many children show some of them at times.

## High standards, or perfectionism?

| High standards | Perfectionism |
| --- | --- |
| Enjoys doing well | Is afraid of doing badly |
| Learns from mistakes | Hides or avoids mistakes |
| Can finish and move on | Can't stop fixing, or can't start |
| Proud of the effort | Satisfied only by perfect |

High standards are worth keeping. The aim is to take the fear out of them.

## What helps

1. **Talk about mistakes as information.** "What does this tell us?" rather than "Oh no."
2. **Share your own mistakes,** and what you did next: "I burnt the rice. Next time I'll set a timer." In one set of experiments, babies who watched an adult try several ways before succeeding made more attempts at a hard task themselves (Leonard and colleagues, 2017).
3. **Praise the process.** "You tried three different endings" works better than "That's perfect". In studies with fifth graders, children praised for being clever cared more about looking good than learning, and coped worse with setbacks (Mueller and Dweck, 1998).
4. **Set time limits, not quality targets.** "Ten minutes of writing, then we stop" is easier to start than "Write a good story."
5. **Use "finished, then better".** Today, get it finished. Tomorrow, make one thing better.
6. **Let them be a beginner.** A new hobby where nobody is good yet, including you.
7. **Read stories where characters get it wrong.** See the books below.

## Writing: the messy first draft

- **Call it a "messy draft".** Its only job is to exist.
- **No rubbing out in the first draft.** Cross out with one line and keep going.
- **Write fast.** Set a timer and write the whole story in ten minutes.
- **Talk it first.** Say the story out loud, then write it down.
- **Fix later, as a separate job.** Spelling and neatness are for the second go.
- **Use a whiteboard or scrap paper.** It feels less permanent.

For a simple shape that makes starting easier, see [story writing for kids](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/story-writing-for-kids). For writing nobody marks, try [journal prompts for kids](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/journal-prompts-for-kids), and if writing has become a battle, see [my child hates writing](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/my-child-hates-writing-why-it-happens-and-what-helps).

## Reading aloud without fear

- **Practise the page silently first,** so there are no surprises.
- **Read to a pet or a teddy.** They never correct anyone.
- **Echo reading:** you read a sentence, they read it after you.
- **Read together:** your voices side by side, so no single mistake stands out.
- **Don't correct every slip.** If the meaning is right, let it go and talk about the story instead.

See [how to build reading confidence](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/how-to-build-reading-confidence-in-children) for more.

## Want a mentor to help with this?

Real sessions

- Talks through a story
- Writes their own story
- Your report on WhatsApp

[Book their free session](https://bookstaken.com/freeTrial)

No payment details needed

[See how the classes work →](https://bookstaken.com/creative-writing-classes-for-kids)

## Books where characters get it wrong

| Book | Age (source) | Why it helps |
| --- | --- | --- |
| [Beautiful Oops!](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/books/beautiful-oops) | Bookstaken's catalogue suggests 6–8 | Spills, tears and smudges turn into new pictures |
| [The Dot](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/books/the-dot) | Catalogue suggests 6–8 | Vashti thinks she can't draw, until one angry dot changes everything |
| [Ish](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/books/ish) | Catalogue suggests 6–8 | Ramon's drawings don't look "right", but they're "vase-ish", and that's enough |
| [Rosie Revere, Engineer](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/books/rosie-revere-engineer) | Catalogue suggests 6–8 | Rosie's flying machine crashes, and her great-great-aunt cheers the first try |

For more, see our [growth mindset books for kids](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/growth-mindset-books-for-kids).

## By age

| Age | What works |
| --- | --- |
| 6–8 | Picture books about mistakes, whiteboards for first drafts, reading to a teddy |
| 9–11 | Messy drafts with a timer, a "mistake of the day" story at dinner, a new hobby nobody is good at yet |
| 12–14 | Talking about the pressure they feel, "good enough" targets for homework, hearing about your own setbacks |

## When to get more help

If perfectionism comes with worries that won't settle, trouble sleeping, avoiding school, or giving up things they used to enjoy, talk to your child's teacher or your doctor.

## A story, chapter by chapter

In a Bookstaken session, your child reads a real book picked for their interests and talks it through one to one with a trained college mentor on Google Meet. At the Review stop, they give their own verdict on the book: an opinion, not a test. Then they write a story of their own, chapter by chapter, which goes into a digital story journal.

After every session, you get a report on WhatsApp. The first 60-minute session is free, and it includes storytelling and writing as well as talking through a story. [See how it works](https://bookstaken.com/creative-writing-classes-for-kids).

## Questions parents ask

### How do I help my child who is a perfectionist?

Make mistakes normal by sharing your own, praise effort and process rather than results, set time limits instead of quality targets, and separate first drafts from corrections.

### What are the signs of perfectionism in a child?

Rubbing out again and again, not starting until they're sure of success, tears over small mistakes, avoiding reading aloud or new activities, and brushing off praise.

### Is perfectionism in children a problem?

High standards are healthy. It becomes a problem when fear of mistakes stops a child starting, finishing or trying new things, or comes with worry that won't settle. Then it's worth talking to the teacher or your doctor.

### How do I help a perfectionist child with writing?

Call the first draft a "messy draft", ban rubbing out until it's finished, write against a short timer, and treat spelling and neatness as a separate job for later.

### My child cries when they make a mistake. What should I do?

Stay calm and name the feeling: "That was frustrating." Once they're calm, talk about what the mistake shows and what to try next. Sharing your own mistakes helps too.

## Sources

- Mueller, C. M. and Dweck, C. S. (1998). [Praise for intelligence can undermine children's motivation and performance](https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.75.1.33). Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1).
- Leonard, J. A., Lee, Y. and Schulz, L. E. (2017). [Infants make more attempts to achieve a goal when they see adults persist](https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aan2317). Science, 357(6357).

## Find books your child will actually read

Book lists by age and interest for kids aged 6–14, every book checked for age-appropriate content.

- [Best books for 7 year olds](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/books-for-7-year-olds)
- [Best books for 10 year olds](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/books-for-10-year-olds)
- [Best books for 12 year olds](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations/books-for-12-year-olds)

Want a list made for your child? [Take the free 2-minute book quiz](https://bookstaken.com/book-recommendations#quiz) and get seven books matched to their age and interests.

More guides on this topic: [Feelings and friendships](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/topics/feelings-and-friendships)

[perfectionist child](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=perfectionist%20child) [my child is a perfectionist](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=my%20child%20is%20a%20perfectionist) [signs of perfectionism in children](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=signs%20of%20perfectionism%20in%20children) [how to help a perfectionist child](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=how%20to%20help%20a%20perfectionist%20child) [perfectionist child writing](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=perfectionist%20child%20writing) [child afraid of making mistakes](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=child%20afraid%20of%20making%20mistakes) [child cries when makes a mistake](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=child%20cries%20when%20makes%20a%20mistake) [perfectionism in kids](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=perfectionism%20in%20kids) [child rubs out work over and over](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=child%20rubs%20out%20work%20over%20and%20over) [books about mistakes for kids](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=books%20about%20mistakes%20for%20kids) [how to help a child who is afraid to fail](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=how%20to%20help%20a%20child%20who%20is%20afraid%20to%20fail) [bookstaken blogs](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/search?q=bookstaken%20blogs)

### Latest Articles

[Why Do Kids Reread the Same Book? (And Why It's Good) 6 min](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/why-do-kids-reread-the-same-book) [Why Dads Reading Aloud Matters (and How to Start) 7 min](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/why-dads-reading-aloud-matters)

### Similar Articles

[Growth Mindset Phrases for Frustrated Kids: What to Say Instead 7 min](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/growth-mindset-phrases-for-kids) [Why Do Kids Reread the Same Book? (And Why It's Good) 6 min](https://bookstaken.com/Blogs/why-do-kids-reread-the-same-book)

### Want Your Child to Experience Books More Deeply?

Bookstaken pairs kids with caring mentors who turn reading into engaging conversations, inspiring them to eventually write their own stories.

## Responses

No responses yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Love books yourself? [Get paid to read with kids as a Bookbuddy](https://bookstaken.com/Become-a-Mentor)
