
Age rating and parents' guide:The black circle
by Patrick Carman
Ages 8–12
The black circle by Patrick Carman is best for children aged 8–12. It has mild violence, a few mildly scary moments, no romance and no bad language.
"A strange telegram lures fourteen-year-old Amy Cahill and her younger brother, Dan, deep into Russia and away from the only trustworthy adult they know.
Content ratings
How much of each a parent can expect, from none to strong.
- Violence
- Mild
- Scary moments
- Mild
- Romance
- None
- Bad language
- None
Content ratings checked by the Bookstaken team, on .
At a glance
- Novel
- Part of the The 39 clues -- bk. 5; 39 clues series
Books like The black circle
Similar stories for the same ages, none more intense than this one should be for its youngest readers.

Ages 8–12
Battle for Arcanum
by Tom Sniegoski
Timothy and Cassandra have defeated the sorcerer Alhazred but in so doing have weakened the dimensional barrier which had prevented the Wurm from…

Ages 8–12
Pollyanna
by Eleanor Hodgman Porter
When young orphan Pollyanna Whittier goes to live with her strict Aunt Polly in Vermont, she brings with her the 'Glad Game' taught by her late father—finding something to be glad about in every situation. Through her irrepressible cheerfulness, Pollyanna gradually transforms the lives of the town's lonely, bitter, and sick residents.

Ages 8–12
How to Cheat a Dragon's Curse
by Cressida Cowell
When Hiccup's best friend Fishlegs is stung by a Venomous Vorpent, Hiccup must embark on a dangerous frozen quest to find the only known cure. Facing icy blizzards, hostile tribes, and terrifying dragons, he has to rely on his wits to save his friend before time runs out.

Ages 8–12
The curse of Mousebeard
by Alex Milway
For many years, a curse has condemned Mousebeard to a life forever lived at sea.

Ages 8–12
Misadventures of Max Crumbly 2: Middle School Mayhem
by Rachel Renée Russell
Max Crumbly finds himself trapped inside South Ridge Middle School overnight after getting locked in his locker. When a pair of burglars breaks in to steal the school's computers, Max must channel his inner superhero to stop them without getting caught.

Ages 8–12
Goblins in the Castle
by Bruce Coville
William lives in Toad-in-a-Cage Castle, where mysterious moans echo from the dungeons at midnight. When he unlocks a forbidden door out of curiosity, he unleashes a horde of silly goblins into the castle. William and his friend Igor must work together to contain the wild creatures and save the kingdom from chaos.
A free 1:1 reading session for your child
- Talks through a story
- Writes their own story
- Your report on WhatsApp
A good book is the start. A mentor makes it stick.
In a free 1:1 session, a trained Bookstaken mentor reads with your child, asks what they think and helps the reading habit last.
- No payment details needed
- Pause anytime
- Switch mentors free
Questions parents ask
Q: What age is The black circle for?
Q: Is The black circle appropriate for a 8 year old?
Q: Is The black circle part of a series?
Q: What should my child read after The black circle?
Love books yourself? Get paid to read with kids as a Bookbuddy