
Age rating and parents' guide:Which Witch?
by Eva Ibbotson
Ages 8–12
Which Witch? by Eva Ibbotson is best for children aged 8–12. It has mild violence, a few mildly scary moments, no romance and no bad language.
Arriman the Awful, a powerful wizard tired of being evil alone, holds a grand competition to choose a witch bride who can perform the most impressive magical feat.
Content ratings
How much of each a parent can expect, from none to strong.
- Violence
- Mild
- Scary moments
- Mild
- Romance
- None
- Bad language
- None
Content ratings checked by the Bookstaken team, on .
At a glance
- Novel
Books like Which Witch?
Similar stories for the same ages, none more intense than this one should be for its youngest readers.

Ages 8–12
Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator
by Roald Dahl
Following the events of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Charlie Bucket and his family board Willy Wonka's Great Glass Elevator, only to be accidentally launched into orbit for an extraordinary high-flying space adventure.

Ages 8–12
Mustaches for Maddie
by Chad Morris
Twelve-year-old Maddie loves making people laugh by carrying around a box of fake mustaches to wear at school. But when her arm starts behaving strangely, medical tests reveal a brain tumor, forcing her to face surgery and serious health challenges with the help of her friends, family, and unique sense of humor.

Ages 8–12
Call It Courage
by Armstrong Sperry
Set in the South Seas long before the arrival of traders and missionaries, this historical adventure follows a young Polynesian boy who must overcome his paralyzing fear of the sea and prove his bravery to his people.

Ages 8–12
The Sight
by Erin Hunter
Three young kit siblings in ThunderClan begin training to become full warriors as a mysterious prophecy unfolds. As Jaypaw, Hollypaw, and Lionpaw discover their unique talents, tensions grow between the cat clans. Together they must learn to protect their territory while uncovering the secrets of their destiny.

Ages 8–12
Lulu Walks the Dogs
by Judith Viorst; Lane Smith
Lulu decides to start a dog-walking business to earn money for a special treat. Handling three unruly dogs with completely different personalities proves much harder than she planned. With the help of a neighborhood boy, she must figure out how to keep the pets under control.

Ages 8–12
Turtle in Paradise
by Jennifer L. Holm
Eleven-year-old Turtle is smart, tough, and used to taking care of herself. Sent to live with extended family in Key West, Florida during the Great Depression of 1935, she navigates life with her quirky cousins—the Diaper Gang—and uncovers family secrets and hidden treasure in a changing world.
A free 1:1 reading session for your child
- Talks through a story
- Writes their own story
- Your report on WhatsApp
A good book is the start. A mentor makes it stick.
In a free 1:1 session, a trained Bookstaken mentor reads with your child, asks what they think and helps the reading habit last.
Questions parents ask
Q: What age is Which Witch? for?
Q: Is Which Witch? appropriate for a 8 year old?
Q: What should my child read after Which Witch??
Love books yourself? Get paid to read with kids as a Bookbuddy