Choosing between books
Famous Five or Secret Seven?
Two Enid Blyton mystery series. One is shorter and starts younger.

Both are Enid Blyton mysteries in which children solve the case with little help from adults. The Secret Seven are seven friends with a club, a password and a garden shed, solving mysteries close to home in short books; Hachette lists book 1 with an interest age from about 6 or 7. The Famous Five are four cousins and a dog on holiday adventures, in longer books; Hachette lists Five on a Treasure Island from about 9. For a younger reader, start with the Secret Seven. For one ready for longer chapter books, try the Famous Five.
The differences at a glance
| What matters to your reader | Famous Five | Secret Seven |
|---|---|---|
| Length | Longer chapter books. | Short books with short chapters. |
| Story world | Islands, smugglers’ caves and secret passages, on school holidays. | A club that meets in a garden shed and solves mysteries near home. |
| Who’s in it | Julian, Dick, Anne, their cousin George and Timmy the dog. | Peter, Janet and five friends, with Scamper the dog. |
| Publisher ages | Hachette: interest age from about 9 (Five on a Treasure Island, ISBN 9781444935011). | Hachette: interest age from about 6 or 7 (The Secret Seven, ISBN 9781444913439). |
| A conversation to try | Which of the five would you want with you on the island, and why? | What rules would your own secret club have? |
| Where to begin | Five on a Treasure Island. | The Secret Seven. |
Choose by length
The Secret Seven books are short, with simple mysteries close to home, so a newer reader can finish one in a few sittings. The Famous Five books are longer and the adventures go further: islands, caves, storms. Many children read the Secret Seven first and move on to the Famous Five. Reading both is fine.
Which came first?
The Famous Five, in 1942, with Five on a Treasure Island. The Secret Seven followed in 1949. There are 21 Famous Five novels and 15 Secret Seven books.
What about the old-fashioned bits?
Both series were written between the 1940s and the 1960s, and it shows: who does the cooking, what girls are expected to do, some old words. Some newer printings update the wording. Talk about it as you read. George, who insists on being treated like a boy, is an easy way in.
A five-minute way to choose
- Read the first page of each aloud.
- Ask: a club with a password, or an island with a castle?
- Start the one they pick. The other makes a good next series.
Questions parents ask
Which is better, Famous Five or Secret Seven?
Neither is better for every child. The Secret Seven suits a younger reader who wants short mysteries; the Famous Five suits one ready for longer adventures. Many children read both.
Which came first, Famous Five or Secret Seven?
The Famous Five, in 1942. The first Secret Seven book was published in 1949.
Is the Secret Seven for younger readers than the Famous Five?
Yes. Hachette lists The Secret Seven from about 6 or 7, and Five on a Treasure Island from about 9. The Secret Seven books are also shorter.








