Choosing between books
Harry Potter or The Lord of the Rings?
Two famous fantasies, a few years apart in reading age. Harry Potter starts younger; The Lord of the Rings asks more of its reader.


Both are long fantasy stories about a young hero and a growing darkness. In Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone (1997), an orphan finds out he is a wizard and starts at Hogwarts. In The Fellowship of the Ring (1954), Frodo sets out to carry a dangerous ring across Middle-earth. BookTrust gives the first Harry Potter book a reading age of 9+, and The Fellowship of the Ring a reading age of 12+.
The differences at a glance
| What matters to your reader | Harry Potter | The Lord of the Rings |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Modern, quick and funny, with lots of dialogue. | Old-fashioned, with long descriptions, songs and history. |
| Setting | A magic school hidden inside our world. | A whole invented world, Middle-earth. |
| How it grows | The books get longer and darker as Harry gets older. | Serious from the start, and it stays long. |
| Content (our catalogue) | Philosopher’s Stone: mild violence, moderate scary moments. | The Fellowship of the Ring: moderate violence and scary moments. |
| Guide ages | BookTrust: interest age 9–14, reading age 9+. | BookTrust: interest age 11+, reading age 12+. |
| Our catalogue | 9–14 | 12–14 |
| Where to begin | Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. | The Hobbit, then The Fellowship of the Ring. |
Choose by what they like
For most children, Harry Potter comes first: it’s easier to read and starts younger. A child who loves big worlds, maps and history, and doesn’t mind a slow start, is ready for The Lord of the Rings, usually from about 12. The Hobbit is the gentler way into Tolkien.
Which came first?
The Lord of the Rings. The Fellowship of the Ring was published in 1954, and Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone in 1997.
Questions parents ask
Is The Lord of the Rings harder to read than Harry Potter?
Yes, for most children. BookTrust gives it a reading age of 12+, against 9+ for the first Harry Potter book.
Should my child read The Hobbit before The Lord of the Rings?
Usually, yes. It’s shorter, lighter, and introduces the ring.
Is Harry Potter darker than The Lord of the Rings?
The first books aren’t. The later Harry Potter books are about as dark, with deaths and a war.






