Bookstaken
Bookstaken
JourneyBook RecommendationsPricing
Become a Bookbuddy
JourneyBook Recommendations
Free Trial
Back

Choosing between books

Percy Jackson or Harry Potter?

Two big fantasy series. Here’s which one may suit your reader first.

Cover of Percy Jackson and the Olympians
orCover of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone

Both are long fantasy novels about a boy who finds out he belongs to a hidden world. Percy Jackson is told by Percy himself, in a fast, jokey voice, with Greek myths loose in modern America; Disney Hyperion lists The Lightning Thief for ages 8–12. Harry Potter is told in the third person and builds its magic school more slowly; BookTrust gives the first book a reading age of 9+. For a reader who loves jokes and action, try Percy Jackson first. For one who likes to settle into a world, try Harry Potter.

In this article

  • The differences at a glance
  • Which is easier to read?
  • What about scary moments?
  • Which came first?
  • A five-minute way to choose
  • Questions parents ask

The differences at a glance

What matters to your readerPercy JacksonHarry Potter
StorytellingPercy narrates, with jokes and funny chapter titles.Told in the third person, building the world chapter by chapter.
Story worldGreek gods and monsters in modern America.A hidden wizarding world and a boarding school in Britain.
Publisher agesDisney Hyperion: 8–12 (The Lightning Thief).BookTrust: interest age 9–14, reading age 9+ (Philosopher’s Stone).
Bookstaken catalogue9–14, moderate violence and scary moments.9–14, moderate scary moments.
A conversation to tryWhich clues would you use to decide who to trust?Do our choices show who we are more than our talents?
Where to beginThe Lightning Thief.Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone (Sorcerer’s Stone in the US).

Find 7 books picked for your child

Free · quick questions

Start the book hunt

A free 1:1 reading session

No payment details needed

Book their free session

Which is easier to read?

Neither has pictures, and both first books run to a few hundred pages. Percy’s short, punchy chapters and jokes can carry a less patient reader. Harry Potter’s description rewards a reader who enjoys picturing a place. Read the first chapter of each aloud, and see which one your child asks to continue.

What about scary moments?

Percy faces monsters from the first chapters, and the catalogue flags monster battles. The first Harry Potter book has moderate scary moments, and the series grows darker as it goes: the catalogue suggests books 1–3 for ages 9–11. Check each later book.

Which came first?

Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone was published in 1997, and The Lightning Thief in 2005. Your child doesn’t need to read one before the other.

A five-minute way to choose

  • Read the first page of each aloud.
  • Ask which world they want to visit: myths in modern America, or a school of magic.
  • Start with one series. The other will still be there.

Questions parents ask

Is Percy Jackson or Harry Potter easier to read?

Neither has pictures. Percy Jackson’s jokey first-person voice and short chapters can feel quicker; Harry Potter builds its world more slowly. Sample a chapter of each together.

Which came first, Percy Jackson or Harry Potter?

Harry Potter, in 1997. The Lightning Thief was published in 2005.

Does this cover the films and TV series?

No. This comparison covers the first books. The films and TV series are adaptations with their own ratings.

Books like Percy Jackson and Harry Potter

More big fantasy adventures with a world to explore.

  • Cover of Magnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard

    Ages 12–14

    Magnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard

    by Rick Riordan

    After dying in battle, Boston teenager Magnus Chase awakens in Hotel Valhalla and discovers that Norse mythology is entirely real—and he is the son of a god. Encourages gentle, guided conversations about challenging feelings and experiences.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of The Chronicles of Narnia

    Ages 9–14

    The Chronicles of Narnia

    by C.S. Lewis

    This classic series transports children from our world into the magical realm of Narnia, a land of talking beasts, mythical creatures, and ancient magic. Guided by the noble lion Aslan, young heroes embark on perilous quests and face formidable foes like the White Witch. Invites readers to discover and appreciate rich storytelling traditions.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of The Land of Stories

    Ages 9–11

    The Land of Stories

    by Chris Colfer

    After losing their father, twins Alex and Conner receive a cherished fairy-tale book from their grandmother that unexpectedly acts as a portal into a magical realm. Encourages gentle, guided conversations about challenging feelings and experiences.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of The Girl Who Drank the Moon

    Ages 9–14

    The Girl Who Drank the Moon

    by Kelly Barnhill

    Every year, the people of the Protectorate leave a baby in the forest as an offering to a witch they fear. But Xan is kind, rescuing the infants and finding them loving homes. Offers space for thoughtful conversations about empathy and difficult choices.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of The Mysterious Benedict Society

    Ages 9–14

    The Mysterious Benedict Society

    by Trenton Lee Stewart

    After responding to a peculiar newspaper advertisement, four remarkably gifted orphans pass a series of mind-bending tests. Recruited by the eccentric Mr Benedict, Reynie, Sticky, Kate, and Constance are sent on an undercover mission to the Learning Institute for the Very Enlightened. Encourages young readers to reflect on belonging and being a good friend.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of Wings of Fire (dragon series)

    Ages 9–14

    Wings of Fire (dragon series)

    by Tui T. Sutherland

    In a world torn apart by a bitter war between dragon tribes, five young dragonets are raised in secret to fulfill a mysterious prophecy and bring peace. Instead of following the path laid out for them, they decide to escape and find their real families. Keeps curiosity alive and invites readers to imagine what comes next.

    Age & content guideGet book

Keep exploring

  • Percy Jackson: age rating and reading order →
  • Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone: age guide →
  • Books like Harry Potter →
  • Books like Percy Jackson →

Find their next favourite book

Get seven free picks based on your child’s age, interests and reading preferences, with a printable list on WhatsApp.

Get my child’s free book list

A story worth talking about

Want a reading companion for your child? In a free 1:1 session, a trained Bookbuddy reads and discusses a story with them, with space for their own ideas.

Ages 6–14 · 60 minutes · Online · No payment details needed

Try a free 1:1 session

Sources and scope

Publisher information and samples introduce the books. The reading prompts are suggestions to try together. Check the exact edition and your child’s comfort before choosing.

  • Disney Books: The Lightning Thief
  • Rick Riordan’s official series guide
  • BookTrust: Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone

Love books yourself? Get paid to read with kids as a Bookbuddy

Bookstaken Logo

We are building the generation that reads the fine print, questions the narrative, and writes their own future. One chapter at a time.

The Path

  • The Curriculum
  • Outcomes
  • Meet the Mentors
  • Online Reading Tutor
  • Reading Comprehension Classes
  • Creative Writing Classes
  • Communication Skills Classes
  • Book Discussions for Kids
  • Reading Tutor from India
  • Reading Tutor Cost Guide
  • What Comes After Phonics?
  • Help Your Child Write a Book
  • Story Ideas for Kids
  • Best Online Reading Programs
  • Blogs
  • Success Stories
  • Pricing & Plans
  • Experience

Book Lists

  • Free Book Recommendations
  • Parents' Guides A–Z
  • Indian Books for Kids
  • Books for Reluctant Readers
  • Sudha Murty Books
  • Winter Break Reading Plan
  • Summer Reading Plan
  • Graphic Novels to Chapter Books
  • Books for Advanced Readers
  • Reading Help by Age

The Club

  • About the Founders
  • Become a BookbuddyBecome a Bookbuddy
  • Join Parent Community

Here for You

  • Talk to a Founder
  • Parents' Guide
  • Contact Us

Privacy and Terms

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Happiness Guarantee (Refund Policy)
  • Cookie Policy

#Made with for kids

© 2026 Bookstaken Pvt. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Book a free trial

🎓 Personally Matched College Mentor - Online

Bookstaken