Choosing between books
Percy Jackson or Harry Potter?
Two big fantasy series. Here’s which one may suit your reader first.


Both are long fantasy novels about a boy who finds out he belongs to a hidden world. Percy Jackson is told by Percy himself, in a fast, jokey voice, with Greek myths loose in modern America; Disney Hyperion lists The Lightning Thief for ages 8–12. Harry Potter is told in the third person and builds its magic school more slowly; BookTrust gives the first book a reading age of 9+. For a reader who loves jokes and action, try Percy Jackson first. For one who likes to settle into a world, try Harry Potter.
The differences at a glance
| What matters to your reader | Percy Jackson | Harry Potter |
|---|---|---|
| Storytelling | Percy narrates, with jokes and funny chapter titles. | Told in the third person, building the world chapter by chapter. |
| Story world | Greek gods and monsters in modern America. | A hidden wizarding world and a boarding school in Britain. |
| Publisher ages | Disney Hyperion: 8–12 (The Lightning Thief). | BookTrust: interest age 9–14, reading age 9+ (Philosopher’s Stone). |
| Bookstaken catalogue | 9–14, moderate violence and scary moments. | 9–14, moderate scary moments. |
| A conversation to try | Which clues would you use to decide who to trust? | Do our choices show who we are more than our talents? |
| Where to begin | The Lightning Thief. | Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone (Sorcerer’s Stone in the US). |
Which is easier to read?
Neither has pictures, and both first books run to a few hundred pages. Percy’s short, punchy chapters and jokes can carry a less patient reader. Harry Potter’s description rewards a reader who enjoys picturing a place. Read the first chapter of each aloud, and see which one your child asks to continue.
What about scary moments?
Percy faces monsters from the first chapters, and the catalogue flags monster battles. The first Harry Potter book has moderate scary moments, and the series grows darker as it goes: the catalogue suggests books 1–3 for ages 9–11. Check each later book.
Which came first?
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone was published in 1997, and The Lightning Thief in 2005. Your child doesn’t need to read one before the other.
A five-minute way to choose
- Read the first page of each aloud.
- Ask which world they want to visit: myths in modern America, or a school of magic.
- Start with one series. The other will still be there.
Questions parents ask
Is Percy Jackson or Harry Potter easier to read?
Neither has pictures. Percy Jackson’s jokey first-person voice and short chapters can feel quicker; Harry Potter builds its world more slowly. Sample a chapter of each together.
Which came first, Percy Jackson or Harry Potter?
Harry Potter, in 1997. The Lightning Thief was published in 2005.
Does this cover the films and TV series?
No. This comparison covers the first books. The films and TV series are adaptations with their own ratings.








