Bookstaken
Bookstaken
JourneyBook RecommendationsPricing
Become a Bookbuddy
JourneyBook Recommendations
Free Trial
Back

Choosing between books

Captain Underpants or Dog Man?

Same author, same kind of jokes, two different ways of reading.

Cover of Captain Underpants
orCover of Dog Man

Both are by Dav Pilkey, and in the stories, George and Harold from Captain Underpants are the ones who make the Dog Man comics. The difference is on the page. Captain Underpants is an illustrated chapter book with comic sections; Dog Man is a full-colour graphic novel told entirely in panels. Scholastic labels the first book of each 7+. For a child who wants pictures all the way through, start with Dog Man; for one ready for some chapters, try Captain Underpants.

In this article

  • The differences at a glance
  • Which is the next step?
  • What about the humour?
  • A five-minute way to choose
  • Questions parents ask

The differences at a glance

What matters to your readerCaptain UnderpantsDog Man
StorytellingIllustrated chapters, with comic sections in between.Comic panels and speech bubbles throughout.
The storyTwo friends hypnotise their head teacher into a superhero.A part-dog, part-police hero protects the city.
Publisher agesScholastic: 7+ (book 1, anniversary edition).Scholastic: 7+ (book 1).
Bookstaken catalogue6–116–11
What to sampleCan they follow a page of text between the comics?Can they follow the panels in order?
Where to beginThe Adventures of Captain Underpants.Dog Man, book 1.

Find 7 books picked for your child

Free · quick questions

Start the book hunt

A free 1:1 reading session

No payment details needed

Book their free session

Which is the next step?

If your child loves Dog Man and is curious about chapters, Captain Underpants is the gentlest move: the jokes feel familiar, and the comic sections break up the text. Going the other way is fine too. Neither replaces the other.

What about the humour?

Both have pranks, toilet humour and cartoon battles. In Captain Underpants, many jokes are at the expense of teachers and school rules, so preview them if that style is new to your family.

A five-minute way to choose

  • Open Captain Underpants at a comic section, then at a page of text. Open Dog Man anywhere.
  • Ask which one they want to keep reading.
  • Notice whether the text pages slow them down or keep them going.

Questions parents ask

Is Captain Underpants harder to read than Dog Man?

It has more text: chapters of sentences, with comic sections in between. Dog Man is all comic panels. Sample both to see what your child enjoys.

Who wrote Dog Man and Captain Underpants?

Dav Pilkey wrote and drew both. In the stories, George and Harold, the boys from Captain Underpants, also make the Dog Man comics.

Does this cover the films?

No. This comparison covers the original books. The Captain Underpants and Dog Man films are adaptations.

Books like Captain Underpants and Dog Man

More funny, picture-packed series.

  • Cover of The Bad Guys

    Ages 6–8

    The Bad Guys

    by Aaron Blabey

    Mr. Wolf is tired of being seen as a scary villain, so he rounds up a crew of other misunderstood predators—including Mr. Snake, Mr. Piranha, and Mr. Shark—to do good deeds. A lighthearted choice for sparking laughter and lively conversation.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of Cat Kid Comic Club

    Ages 6–11

    Cat Kid Comic Club

    by Dav Pilkey

    Li'l Petey, Flippy, and Molly host an art class for twenty-one energetic baby frogs to teach them how to make their own comic books. Using a variety of mediums like photography, clay, and haiku, the young frogs learn to express their creativity while navigating self-doubt, failure, and teamwork. Invites children to imagine, create, and share ideas of their own.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of Dragon Masters

    Ages 6–8

    Dragon Masters

    by Tracey West

    Eight-year-old Drake is an ordinary farm boy until he is chosen by the Dragon Stone to become a Dragon Master. Brought to King Roland's castle, he meets three other young masters and discovers his own dragon, a gentle earth dragon named Worm. Invites exciting predictions and plenty of imaginative discussion.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of The 13-Storey Treehouse

    Ages 8–11

    The 13-Storey Treehouse

    by Andy Griffiths & Terry Denton

    Andy and Terry live in an incredible multi-level treehouse packed with amazing inventions, from a see-through swimming pool and a bowling alley to a giant marshmallow machine. The two friends need to write their next book, but absurd distractions keep getting in the way, including flying cats, giant sea monsters, and unruly monkeys. A lighthearted choice for sparking laughter and lively conversation.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of Big Nate

    Ages 9–11

    Big Nate

    by Lincoln Peirce

    Nate Wright is an energetic middle-schooler who is completely convinced he is destined for greatness. Armed with a sketchbook and big ideas, he spends his days navigating detentions, dodging his strict social studies teacher Mrs. Godfrey, and hanging out with his best friends Francis and Teddy. A lighthearted choice for sparking laughter and lively conversation.

    Age & content guideGet book
  • Cover of Mercy Watson

    Ages 6–8

    Mercy Watson

    by Kate DiCamillo

    Meet Mercy Watson, a pampered pig who adores hot buttered toast above all else. When her devoted human parents tuck her into bed, Mercy's hunt for a midnight snack accidentally sparks chaos, bringing the neighbours and local emergency services into a whirlwind of funny misunderstandings.

    Age & content guideGet book

Keep exploring

  • Captain Underpants: age and content guide →
  • Dog Man: age and content guide →
  • More books like Dog Man →
  • Dog Man or The Bad Guys? →

Find their next favourite book

Get seven free picks based on your child’s age, interests and reading preferences, with a printable list on WhatsApp.

Get my child’s free book list

A story worth talking about

Want a reading companion for your child? In a free 1:1 session, a trained Bookbuddy reads and discusses a story with them, with space for their own ideas.

Ages 6–14 · 60 minutes · Online · No payment details needed

Try a free 1:1 session

Sources and scope

Publisher information and samples introduce the books. The reading prompts are suggestions to try together. Check the exact edition and your child’s comfort before choosing.

  • Scholastic: The Adventures of Captain Underpants, anniversary edition
  • Scholastic: Dog Man book 1 and sample

Love books yourself? Get paid to read with kids as a Bookbuddy

Bookstaken Logo

We are building the generation that reads the fine print, questions the narrative, and writes their own future. One chapter at a time.

The Path

  • The Curriculum
  • Outcomes
  • Meet the Mentors
  • Online Reading Tutor
  • Reading Comprehension Classes
  • Creative Writing Classes
  • Communication Skills Classes
  • Book Discussions for Kids
  • Reading Tutor from India
  • Reading Tutor Cost Guide
  • What Comes After Phonics?
  • Help Your Child Write a Book
  • Story Ideas for Kids
  • Best Online Reading Programs
  • Blogs
  • Success Stories
  • Pricing & Plans
  • Experience

Book Lists

  • Free Book Recommendations
  • Parents' Guides A–Z
  • Indian Books for Kids
  • Books for Reluctant Readers
  • Sudha Murty Books
  • Winter Break Reading Plan
  • Summer Reading Plan
  • Graphic Novels to Chapter Books
  • Books for Advanced Readers
  • Reading Help by Age

The Club

  • About the Founders
  • Become a BookbuddyBecome a Bookbuddy
  • Join Parent Community

Here for You

  • Talk to a Founder
  • Parents' Guide
  • Contact Us

Privacy and Terms

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Happiness Guarantee (Refund Policy)
  • Cookie Policy

#Made with for kids

© 2026 Bookstaken Pvt. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Book a free trial

🎓 Personally Matched College Mentor - Online

Bookstaken