Choosing between books
Captain Underpants or Dog Man?
Same author, same kind of jokes, two different ways of reading.


Both are by Dav Pilkey, and in the stories, George and Harold from Captain Underpants are the ones who make the Dog Man comics. The difference is on the page. Captain Underpants is an illustrated chapter book with comic sections; Dog Man is a full-colour graphic novel told entirely in panels. Scholastic labels the first book of each 7+. For a child who wants pictures all the way through, start with Dog Man; for one ready for some chapters, try Captain Underpants.
The differences at a glance
| What matters to your reader | Captain Underpants | Dog Man |
|---|---|---|
| Storytelling | Illustrated chapters, with comic sections in between. | Comic panels and speech bubbles throughout. |
| The story | Two friends hypnotise their head teacher into a superhero. | A part-dog, part-police hero protects the city. |
| Publisher ages | Scholastic: 7+ (book 1, anniversary edition). | Scholastic: 7+ (book 1). |
| Bookstaken catalogue | 6–11 | 6–11 |
| What to sample | Can they follow a page of text between the comics? | Can they follow the panels in order? |
| Where to begin | The Adventures of Captain Underpants. | Dog Man, book 1. |
Which is the next step?
If your child loves Dog Man and is curious about chapters, Captain Underpants is the gentlest move: the jokes feel familiar, and the comic sections break up the text. Going the other way is fine too. Neither replaces the other.
What about the humour?
Both have pranks, toilet humour and cartoon battles. In Captain Underpants, many jokes are at the expense of teachers and school rules, so preview them if that style is new to your family.
A five-minute way to choose
- Open Captain Underpants at a comic section, then at a page of text. Open Dog Man anywhere.
- Ask which one they want to keep reading.
- Notice whether the text pages slow them down or keep them going.
Questions parents ask
Is Captain Underpants harder to read than Dog Man?
It has more text: chapters of sentences, with comic sections in between. Dog Man is all comic panels. Sample both to see what your child enjoys.
Who wrote Dog Man and Captain Underpants?
Dav Pilkey wrote and drew both. In the stories, George and Harold, the boys from Captain Underpants, also make the Dog Man comics.
Does this cover the films?
No. This comparison covers the original books. The Captain Underpants and Dog Man films are adaptations.








