Choosing between books
Dog Man or The Bad Guys?
Two funny, picture-packed series. One tells the story in comic panels, the other in short illustrated chapters.


For a child who prefers pictures, start with Dog Man. It is a full-colour graphic novel told in comic panels, so the pictures carry most of the story. The Bad Guys is an illustrated chapter book: big drawings on every page, with the story told through speech and short stretches of text across chapters. If your child already loves Dog Man, The Bad Guys is a good next step toward more words. Scholastic lists Dog Man book 1 for ages 7 and up and The Bad Guys Episode 1 for ages 7–10.
The differences at a glance
| What matters to your reader | Dog Man | The Bad Guys |
|---|---|---|
| Storytelling | Full-colour comic panels and speech bubbles. | Short chapters, with a big drawing on every page. |
| Story interests | A part-dog, part-police hero against a villain cat. | Animals with scary reputations trying to be heroes. |
| Publisher ages | Scholastic: 7 and up (book 1). | Scholastic: 7–10 (Episode 1). |
| What to sample | Can they follow the panels in order? | Do they keep going when the text carries more of the story? |
| A conversation to try | How do the pictures show a feeling nobody says out loud? | What makes someone a good guy: how they look, or what they do? |
| Where to begin | Dog Man, book 1, by Dav Pilkey. | The Bad Guys, Episode 1, by Aaron Blabey. |
Choose by how they like to read
If your child reaches for comics, start with Dog Man: the pictures do most of the work, so a whole book feels quick. If they love comics but are curious about chapter books, The Bad Guys keeps the jokes and the pictures and gives the words a bigger share of the story. Reading both is fine.
What about the humour?
Both are silly. Dog Man has cartoon fights and toilet humour, and the catalogue flags mild language. The Bad Guys has comic action and rude jokes.
The linked guides show Bookstaken’s catalogue ages: Dog Man 6–11, The Bad Guys 6–8. Use them, with the publishers’ guidance, as a starting point alongside your child’s comfort.
A five-minute way to choose
- Open each book at chapter one and give your child two minutes with each.
- Ask which one they want to finish, and what made them laugh.
- If they pick Dog Man today, offer The Bad Guys again in a few months.
Questions parents ask
Is The Bad Guys harder to read than Dog Man?
It has more words: more of the story is in speech and short passages of text. Dog Man is told in comic panels. Neither is a test, so sample both.
Is The Bad Guys a graphic novel?
It is usually called an illustrated chapter book: chapters with big drawings on every page. Scholastic also publishes colour editions and film novelisations, so check the title before buying.
What should my child read after Dog Man?
Illustrated chapter books are the next step: Captain Underpants, The Bad Guys, Dragon Masters and Mercy Watson. Books like Dog Man has more.







