Choosing between books
Tom Gates or Diary of a Wimpy Kid?
Two funny school notebooks. Here’s how they differ on the page.


Both are funny school stories written as a boy’s own notebook, with drawings. Tom Gates fills more of each page with doodles, lettering and lists, and is set in a British school; Scholastic lists book 1 for ages 7–8. Diary of a Wimpy Kid has longer stretches of writing between cartoons and follows Greg through American middle school; Abrams lists it for ages 8–12. For a younger reader who loves drawing, try Tom Gates first. For a reader ready for more text on the page, try Wimpy Kid.
The differences at a glance
| What matters to your reader | Tom Gates | Diary of a Wimpy Kid |
|---|---|---|
| Storytelling | Writing, doodles, lettering and lists fill each page. | Journal entries with a cartoon on most pages. |
| Setting | A British school. | An American middle school. |
| Story interests | Tom’s band, his big sister and dodging homework. | Greg’s schemes, his family and his friend Rowley. |
| Publisher ages | Scholastic UK: 7–8 (book 1). | Abrams: 8–12. |
| A conversation to try | Which doodle tells you most about how Tom feels? | Would Greg’s friend tell this moment the same way? |
| Where to begin | The Brilliant World of Tom Gates, by Liz Pichon. | Diary of a Wimpy Kid, by Jeff Kinney. |
Choose by how they like to read
A child who loves drawing and busy pages may take to Tom Gates first. A child who likes a running joke and a bit more text may prefer Greg’s journal. They work well as a pair.
What about behaviour?
Both boys dodge homework, tease their families and stretch the truth. In Wimpy Kid, Greg’s selfishness is often the joke. In Tom Gates, the trouble is mostly mischief. Talk about their choices rather than treating them as advice.
A five-minute way to choose
- Open each book at any page and ask your child to find the funniest thing.
- Notice whether they read the words or only the pictures. Either is a start.
- Let them choose which to finish first.
Questions parents ask
Which is better, Tom Gates or Diary of a Wimpy Kid?
Neither is better for every child. Tom Gates suits a reader who loves doodles and lettering; Wimpy Kid suits one ready for more writing on the page. Let your child sample both.
Is Tom Gates for younger readers than Wimpy Kid?
Scholastic UK lists Tom Gates book 1 for ages 7–8, and Abrams lists Wimpy Kid for 8–12. Bookstaken’s catalogue suggests 9–11 for Wimpy Kid. Use these as starting points.
Which came first, Tom Gates or Wimpy Kid?
Diary of a Wimpy Kid was published in 2007. The Brilliant World of Tom Gates followed in 2011.








