Is Online Tutoring Effective for Kids? What the Evidence Says

What research shows about one-to-one tutoring, whether it works as well online, what makes it work, and a checklist for choosing.

By Bookstaken19 November 20267 min read
Is Online Tutoring Effective for Kids? What the Evidence Says

It's late, and you have three tabs open. Each promises your child will "love learning", "jump two grades" or "finally catch up". Your nine-year-old is either struggling or bored, you're not sure which, and you wonder whether an hour on a screen with a stranger could really help.

It's a fair question. The good news is that tutoring has been studied a great deal. The catch is that quality varies enormously, and online adds a few things to check.

In short

  • One-to-one tutoring works, on average. The Education Endowment Foundation (EEF) puts it at about five months of extra progress over a year, and six in literacy.
  • Online can work too. The EEF reports broadly similar effects in studies using digital technology, and a trial in Italy found online tutoring by university students raised children's school performance and wellbeing.
  • Quality matters most: trained tutors, a clear structure, regular sessions and a link to what your child actually needs.
  • Choose carefully. Check who the tutors are, ask for a trial, sit in, and expect regular feedback.

What research says about one-to-one tutoring

The EEF's Teaching and Learning Toolkit, a summary of research used by schools in England, rates one-to-one tuition at around five additional months' progress on average.

Behind the average:

  • Studies in primary schools show more impact (six months) than in secondary schools (four months).
  • Effects in literacy (six months) are much larger than in maths (two months).
  • Children who are behind, and those from poorer families, tend to benefit most.

The EEF also notes that short, regular sessions, about 30 minutes three to five times a week for up to ten weeks, appear to work best for catch-up support, and that tutoring should be linked to what children are learning in class.

Does it work as well online?

The evidence is younger, but encouraging.

The EEF says studies involving digital technology show broadly similar effects to tutoring in person.

During the 2020 school closures in Italy, researchers tested an online programme in which volunteer university students tutored middle-school children from disadvantaged families for at least three hours a week. Compared with similar children who weren't tutored, the children's academic performance rose by 0.26 standard deviations, a sizeable gain, and their socioemotional skills, aspirations and psychological wellbeing improved too (Carlana and La Ferrara, 2021).

That last finding matters. Good tutoring isn't only about marks. A child with one adult's full attention often grows in confidence as well.

What makes tutoring work

The research points to a few active ingredients:

  • Training and structure. The EEF notes that tutoring by volunteers or teaching assistants can have a valuable impact, but may be less effective than tutoring by experienced, specifically trained teachers, and that training and a structured programme are advisable.
  • Regular sessions. A steady rhythm beats occasional bursts.
  • A clear goal. Tutoring works best when it targets what your child needs, whether that's catching up, being stretched or getting interested again.
  • Feedback. Progress should be checked, and you should hear about it.
  • A real relationship. Children work harder for someone who knows them and listens.

What online can't do

  • It needs a quiet space. A shared room with a television on makes focus hard.
  • Younger children tire on screens. Shorter or more interactive sessions help.
  • It's not a replacement for school. Good tutoring adds to what happens in class.
  • Quality is hard to judge from adverts. Big promises are easy to make online.

A checklist for choosing an online tutor

QuestionWhat a good answer looks like
Who are the tutors, and how are they checked?Named checks: identity, qualifications or college ID, and a selection process
Are tutors trained?Training before the first session, not just a subject test
Is there a structure?A clear shape to each session, not an open video call
Can we try first?A free or low-cost trial session
Can I sit in?Yes, at least at the start
Will I hear how it's going?Regular, specific feedback after sessions
Can we change tutors?Yes, without fuss
Is the price clear?Prices shown upfront, and clear terms if you want to stop
Is it the right kind of help?Exam tutoring, a reading mentor and specialist support (for dyslexia, for example) are different things

A mentor who truly listens

Real sessions
  • Talks through a story
  • Writes their own story
  • Your report on WhatsApp

Keeping it safe

  • Sessions happen on a platform you know, with a link you control.
  • You're nearby, at least for the first sessions, and your child knows they can call you.
  • There are no private messages between tutor and child outside the platform you agreed.
  • Your child knows they can tell you if anything ever feels wrong.

What kind of help does your child need?

The free session, and you're welcome to sit in

Bookstaken is a reading mentor, not exam tutoring. In a Bookstaken session, your child reads a real book picked for their interests and talks it through one to one with a trained college mentor on Google Meet. Each 60-minute session follows the same five stops: an ice-breaker, the book discussion, their own review of the book, writing their own story, and a recap to close.

  • Who the mentors are: college students, from DU, the IITs, the NITs, SRCC and more. About 1 in 100 applicants is accepted. Each mentor's college ID and identity are verified, and every mentor is trained before their first session.
  • How you'll know it's working: a report after every session, on WhatsApp.
  • How you can check: the first session is free, with no payment details, and you're welcome to sit in. Changing mentors is flexible, and you choose how often sessions happen.

Book the free session, or compare options in our guide to the best online reading programmes for kids.

Questions parents ask

Is online tutoring effective for kids?

It can be. One-to-one tuition adds about five months of progress on average, according to the Education Endowment Foundation, which reports broadly similar effects in studies using digital technology. Quality, structure and regular sessions matter more than the format.

Is online tutoring as good as in person?

For many children, it can be. The EEF reports broadly similar effects for digital approaches, and an Italian trial of online tutoring by university students found gains in school performance and wellbeing. Younger children may need shorter or more interactive sessions.

How often should a child have tutoring?

For catch-up support, the EEF found short, regular sessions, about 30 minutes three to five times a week for up to ten weeks, appear to work best. Other kinds of help, such as a reading mentor, may follow a different rhythm. Regular matters more than long.

Is online tutoring safe for children?

It can be, with the right checks: tutors whose identity is verified, sessions on a platform you know, you nearby at the start, and no private messages outside the agreed platform.

How do I choose an online tutor for my child?

Ask how tutors are checked and trained, whether sessions have a structure, whether there's a free trial, whether you can sit in, and how you'll hear about progress. Make sure the help matches what your child needs.

Sources

More guides on this topic: Focus and learning

Want Your Child to Experience Books More Deeply?

Bookstaken pairs kids with caring mentors who turn reading into engaging conversations, inspiring them to eventually write their own stories.

Responses

No responses yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Love books yourself? Get paid to read with kids as a Bookbuddy